Cheeses

Wisconsin cheese can't be bought from an older store in Wisconsin.

Items 1 to 10 of 40 total

per page
Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4

  1. 11 year cheddar

    11 Year Cheddar

    $16.50
    One pound of 11 year Cheddar
    Learn More

  2. 3 Year Cheddar

    3 Year Cheddar

    $8.75
    Sharp and still creamy white Cheddar
    Learn More

  3. 3 year old Swiss

    3 Year Old Block Swiss

    $16.75
    The sharpest Swiss we have.
    Learn More

    Out of stock

  4. 5 Year Yellow Cheddar

    5 Year Yellow Cheddar

    $13.95
    Excellent sharp flavor.
    Learn More

  5. Apple Jack

    Apple Jack

    $10.50
    Mild and Creamy with just a little bite.
    Learn More

  6. Baumies' Box

    Baumies' Gift Box

    $43.50
    Baumgartner's Horseradish Mustard, 2nd Best Chili, and Cheese Slicer, with one pound each of Mild Brick, Baby Swiss, and 5 Year Cheddar. This box is perfect for anyone who can't visit as often as they would like.
    Learn More

    Out of stock

  7. Brun-Uusto

    Brun-Uusto

    $6.75
    This Scandinavian style "bread cheese" comes in just over a half pound piece, and one of four flavors.
    Learn More

  8. Butterkase

    Butterkase

    $7.50
    Buttery goodness
    Learn More

  9. Party Box

    Cheese Party Box

    $94.95
    One pound each of Mild Brick, Baby Swiss, 5 Year Cheddar, Pepper Jack, 3 Year Swiss, Smoked Blue, Horseradish and Chive Farmer, with one jar of our Horseradish Mustard and a two pound smoked Summer Sausage.
    Learn More

    Out of stock

  10. Colby

    Colby

    $8.50
    This is the Colby Longhorn.
    Learn More

Items 1 to 10 of 40 total

per page
Page:
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4